Silicone with Silicone? Heaven Forbid!
Whenever I tell people that my favorite - holy grail level of favorite - pegging lube is Sliquid Silk, and that it's a hybrid lube that's 12% silicone and 88% water based....people freak out.
"NO! In the name of all sex toys that you hold sacred...NEVER combine silicone toys and silicone lube!" They chant.
I was once one of those chanters. Then something happened.
I'm Given Accurate Information
Sex toys are my jam. I go to shows, talk to manufacturers, and test toys. A few years back I remember hearing from the owner of a company that makes the very best silicone lube - Uberlube - that in reality, if you have a quality silicone lube and you use it with a quality silicone toy, there's not a problem. Initially I met that declaration with disbelief, but with time I have come to be a believer.
First let me say that Uberlube, IMO, is not at all suitable for pegging. I prefer a lube that has a thicker consistency to it, some heft. The best lube will mostly stay where I put it, and I like to see it. Uberlube is great for PIV sex, and even better for shower PIV sex. It keeps working and doesn't wash off, but I digress. This claim of compatibility opened my mind to the possibility of silicone-containing lubes for pegging.
The Holy Grail of Pegging Lubes is Discovered
I began to hear the silicone/silicone compatibility claim from others, including quality toy manufacturers. Then I encountered Sliquid Silk. The folks at Sliquid Silk told me that in their experience, there wasn't enough silicone in the formulation to cause problems, even with toys of lesser quality.
So I tried it, and the rest is history. Now, I shout to all who will listen that Sliquid Silk is the Holy Grail of Pegging Lubes.
I have used this lube with toys from Tantus, Fuze, Vixen Creations, Fun Factory, Lelo, and JeJoue. Not one toy was harmed. Ever! When I brought this up in a thread on reddit/pegging, I was told that the lube could be causing 'micro-pitting' and I wouldn't know it. Wow - seriously, people?
You get pretty protective of toys when you pay big bucks for them. I understand the reluctance to test my claims, despite my assurances. But wait, you wonder. If this is really true, why aren't more lube companies putting this information on their websites and even on the bottles?
Why the Myth Exists
Sex toys are unregulated, which means they can tell you that the toy is made of anything they want, and the label could be completely fallacious. There are no repercussions in sex toy world for manufacturers who are dishonest on labels, because sex toys are classified as 'novelties. This technically means that they have no use. They are just for show. Even if they have manufactured the toys with chemicals that have been banned from children's toys and pet toys (yes, this really happens), they can put whatever they want on the label. They don't give a fuck, basically. For (much) more information about that - read this.
Consequently, given that the veracity of the labels is not something you can depend upon, you could have a toy that is not made from silicone at all, despite the claims on the label. There you are, using a silicone lube with it. The toy gets fucked up, you get mad at the manufacturers of the lube, or the toy, or whoever told you that you can combine the two. See the problem? No lube company wants to be held liable for bad toy labeling of poor quality toys and the consequential toy damage.
Try it Yourself!
The compatibility is real. Seriously. I encourage you to use Sliquid Silk for your pegging. Give it a try and let me know what you think!
If, however, you purchased your toy on Amazon for $6, and it has a distinct (and not pleasant) smell, you do not have a quality toy! Read the article linked above and then get a body-safe toy.
Support my work - purchase Sliquid Silk from this link and use the coupon code Ryder for free shipping!
Mr. Hankey's Toys, who manufacture platinum cured 100% silicone toys, has this to say about silicone lube with silicone toys:
What lube can I use with your toys?
Any, even silicone. High-grade platinum silicone does not melt when placed in contact with silicone lube or other silicone toys; this is a myth. Manufacturers of platinum silicone toys who say their toys will melt when placed in contact with other silicone toys or when used with silicone lubricants are either selling something other than high grade platinum silicone, or are not very knowledgeable.